The lawsuit alleges that the Department’s approval fails to meet the requirements of the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA), lacks adequate scientific evidence, and does not properly consider other and better alternatives for managing the deer, such as regulated hunting.
The Catalina Island Conservancy, which submitted the plan to the Department, dismissed hunting as a viable management tool to justify its preferred alternative of the mass slaughter of the island’s deer population. This strategy was based on the flawed premise that mule deer, which are native to California, are “invasive” on the island.
The coalition’s lawsuit seeks to require the plan to undergo a full environmental review under CEQA, including scientific analysis, consideration of alternatives, and opportunities for stakeholder input.
“The California Department of Fish and Wildlife’s approval of a plan to eradicate Catalina Island’s mule deer population is an abdication of leadership in a moment where they could implement balanced, science-based stewardship,” said W. Laird Hamberlin, CEO of Safari Club International. Read more










