A paradox of good intentions is the only description that comes to mind with a story from Texas relative to the Endangered Species Act (ESA). Although the ESA has been with us for some 40 years and is touted as having credible successes with certain species (and, rightfully so), it’s having a severe, negative impact on three antelope species: horned oryx, Dama gazelle and addax. These antelope species are known in Texas as the “Three Amigos.”
The U.S. House and Senate will consider Dallas Safari Club (DSC)-backed legislation that would exempt from ESA protections three antelope species nearly extinct in their native countries but thriving on ranches in Texas. The exemptions would clear the way for ranchers to maintain their herds and to offer hunts for these game animals without government intervention.
Once again, the seemingly counter-intuitive rationale to allow hunting is being used as an argument to save the species. Yes, they are not indigenous to Texas, but tell that to the once-thriving herd.
First, we must understand that the imposition of ESA mandates brings with it certain prohibitions including but not limited to the following: 1) Take—which includes harassing, harming, pursuing, hunting, shooting, wounding, killing, trapping, capturing, collecting, or to attempting any of these—of listed species within the U.S., its territorial waters, or on the high seas. 2) Possess, sell, deliver, carry, transport, or ship listed species taken in violation of the ESA.
Here is how it has played out. The Three Amigos were exempt from 2005 until 2012, when the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service re-listed them under the ESA. Since then, populations have fallen dramatically. The Exotic Wildlife Association estimates that scimitar horned oryx numbers in Texas are now at nearly half of their 2010 levels.
Congressman John Carter of Texas said, “It’s time for the federal government to step out of the way, because ESA status has been deadly for these species. An ESA exemption would give these species real value, and that, in turn, clears the way for their numbers to go back up.”
We can kill the antelope with kindness or we can create a thriving environment through hunting.
The apparent oxymoron is contradicted only by the facts. Hunting is not the only option available to save these creatures, but it is the only viable one being presented.
It takes money. And, all the do-gooders combined in the world will never put their money where their mouths are, unless, of course, they can demonize any form of hunting with help from their deep pockets.
