By Glen Wunderlich
As predicted, Michigan’s deer management strategy continues to be an abysmal failure. And, to prove it, all one has to do is to review the statistics. According to State Farm Insurance, the number of vehicles on U.S. roadways has grown by 7 percent over the last five years. But the number of times those vehicles have collided with deer has swelled by much more than that. Michigan remains second in the nation on the list of states with car/deer crashes – a 1 in 78 chance for any one vehicle to collide with a deer statewide.
Using its claims data, State Farm estimates 2.4 million collisions between deer and vehicles occurred in the U.S. during the two-year period between July 1, 2007 and June 30, 2009 (100,000 per month). That’s 18.3 percent more than five years earlier. To put it another way, one of these unfortunate encounters occurs every 26 seconds (although they are much more likely during the last three months of the year and in the early evening).
These findings are nothing new to us in Michigan but a June 2011 report issued by the Michigan Department of Natural Resources (MDNR) offers some insight on how hunters are impacting the results of deer management policy. In spite of newly created deer hunting seasons that run nearly one third of the entire year, in year 2010 hunter numbers decreased 4 percent and their hunting effort decreased 6 percent from the previous year. Yet, the MDNR’s survey of some 50,000 deer hunters indicated increased satisfaction with their hunting experience. On the surface such news may seem encouraging – that is, until one discovers that over 55 percent of the same hunters surveyed were not satisfied with their overall hunting experience. So, what’s the rub? Read more