SAF files ‘friend of the court’ brief defending Florida FWC Commission rule authorizing bear hunt
On Friday, Nov. 14, the Sportsmen’s Alliance Foundation filed a friend of the court, or amicus curiae, brief opposing an extremist group’s attempt to halt Florida’s first bear hunt in 10 years.
Florida black bears have had a remarkable recovery. They were listed as a threatened species under the state’s equivalent of the Endangered Species Act from 1974-2012. The population has increased from roughly 500 to 4,000 in that timeframe.
After this recovery, a hunt was held in 2015. The Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) lobbied the governor to stop it. HSUS’ lobbying attempts were unsuccessful, and so was a lawsuit filed by Speak Up Wekiva, with support from the Sierra Club and Center for Biological Diversity. The hunt proceeded and 304 bears were harvested across the state’s four bear management units. The harvest quota was hit on the second day of the hunt, and the hunt was shut down accordingly. The controversy surrounding that early closure resulted in the Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission not authorizing any hunts since then, despite keeping the option open when it approved the 2019 bear management plan.
In August 2025, the commission adopted a rule authorizing a hunt to begin December 6. Like the last hunt, that did not go unchallenged. An extremist group called Bear Warriors United has challenged the lawsuit and filed a motion to enjoin the hunt. The suit argues that the hunt is unsupported by science and the commission unconstitutionally delegated its authority to another branch of the government.
Sportsmen’s Alliance Foundation filed a brief opposing that motion and supporting the hunt. The brief argues that hunt was lawfully authorized under the Florida Constitution, was supported by sufficient scientific data, and the plaintiffs have not shown that they will be irreparably harmed by the hunt, which prevents the court from issuing the preliminary injunction. Read more